What is MAHA?

“Make America Healthy Again” otherwise known as MAHA is a public health-focused initiative under the second Trump administration. This movement has been largely spearheaded by Robert F. Kennedy (RFK), who serves as the United States Secretary of Health and Human Services. MAHA aims at addressing the health of Americans. 

 

Some Key Goals of MAHA Include:

      • Improving overall health and life expectancy
      • Decreasing rates of chronic health conditions such as heart disease, diabetes, allergies, asthma, weight concerns etc.
      • Reforming some aspects of America’s food industry such as targeting concerns with processed foods
      • Promotion of disease prevention by incorporating lifestyle changes to improve health 

 

MAHA Reviewed: An Eating Disorder Dietitian’s Take 

As an eating disorder dietitian, I have mixed reviews… 

 

The Positives 

Let’s start with the positives. As a registered dietitian, I support a desire to improve the health of Americans. I will always get behind wanting to decrease the prevalence of chronic disease by implementing health improving behaviors. It’s always reassuring to see these are things that an administration cares about. 

 

The Drawbacks 

The main aspect of MAHA that I caution is the way in which MAHA is communicating to Americans.

MAHA is riddled with fear mongering and shame inducing language 

Just like diet culture… Which is the main beast that I battle daily working with disordered eating and eating disorders so I am very familiar how this is at best, unproductive and at worst, harmful. 

 

Below are a few examples of this: 

Take 30 seconds to watch this ad if you haven’t seen it. It’s truly disheartening to see Mike Tyson use the  words “nasty” and “fudgy” to describe someone in a larger body and to use such strong language including, “self-hate” and “processed food kills” 

Uses trigger words like “unprecedented” “crisis” “alarming” to incite fear 

    • Throughout MAHA there are strong messages around processed foods and general fear-based messaging about the food system

Foods Encouraged by MAHA are Not Being Made More Affordable

While I support eating more fruits, vegetables and whole grains, there is nothing MAHA has done to reform the food systems and make these foods more affordable.

Many Americans cannot afford to feed their families the recommended amount of these types of foods. In fact, the USDA estimates that 18.3 million U.S. households were food insecure at some point in 2024. Eating a diet primarily composed of fresh foods versus processed foods can cost 3-4x more. Eating sufficiently and what MAHA considers “healthfully” are mutually exclusive to families who are lower income. 

Unfortunately, when you are in this position, you are not thinking about how to obtain fresh foods, rather you are thinking about how to get the most bang for your buck and the answer to that is likely going to be processed foods. 

Why Fear Mongering and Shame Inducing Language Doesn’t Actually Work

While slightly scaring or intimidating someone might seem helpful on the surface, it can actually trigger feelings of shame and inaction. For example, someone in a larger body sitting at a superbowl party watching that ad might feel very uncomfortable and ashamed because Mike Tyson just referred to them as “nasty.” 

From my experience, shame is certainly not a motivator to incite change in my clients. Shame typically causes someone to withdraw and avoid rather than addressing what is going on. For example, if I were to shame a client that is engaging in binge-eating behaviors, they are more likely to go home and binge than if I were to approach it in another way -such as, with compassion, validation and understanding. 

 

Final Thoughts: I Don’t Support the New Food Pyramid 

Forget the “eating disorder” specialty of my work, but as a dietitian in general, I don’t support the new food pyramid. 

Let’s talk about why: 

      • I don’t support the idea of labeling foods in a hierarchical way 

I believe that all types of foods can fit in someone’s diet and there is not one food that is “better” than another. Foods are not morally superior and one food does not determine your health. Reinforcing the message that some foods are better than others can increase food guilt which can lead to disordered eating thoughts or behaviors. 

        • If I had to rank foods, carbs are certainly in the wrong place 

The body’s preferred energy source is carbohydrates and the brain only runs on carbohydrates, yet this this at the lowest portion of the pyramid, pushing forth the message that they should comprise the smallest portion of your diet. 

      • A dietitian was not involved in the making of the food pyramid 

I can’t think of a better person to create or at least have a role in creating a new food pyramid than a registered dietitian. As far as I can tell, one was not involved. 

I’m totally here for actually making America healthy, but I don’t love the way in which MAHA is going about it. Let’s not use fear to create change.

If you are feeling triggered by MAHA messaging or think you or someone you love may be struggling with eating behaviors, food thoughts, or body image, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us today! We are all specialized in eating disorders and offer free discovery calls for you to get to know about our practice more before committing to anything else.

haley havighurst

Haley Havighurst, RD, LD

Haley joined Courage to Nourish because she shares an anti-diet, weight neutral philosophy in her treatment strategies and she wanted to work in an outpatient setting to foster deeper connections with clients focusing on helping clients repair their relationships with food
and their bodies. To learn more about Haley and her practice style, click here.

College Park 7307 Baltimore Ave Suite 109 College Park, MD 20740

Columbia
9841 Broken Land Pkwy    Suite 106                        Columbia, MD 21046 

Alexandria
707 Oronoco Street
Alexandria, VA 22314

Virginia Virtual Options:
Richmond, VA
Charlottesville, VA

P: (301) 202-4532 F: (844) 904-0458 E: hello@couragetonourish.com © Copyright Courage to Nourish Nutrition 2023