When it comes to fueling athletic performance, misinformation is everywhere. From gym chatter to social media tips, athletes are often bombarded with advice that sounds convincing but isn’t always backed by science. Believing these myths about nutrition for athletes can actually harm performance, recovery, and overall health. In this blog, we’ll break down five of the most common myths—and share the facts you need to fuel smarter and train stronger.

Myth #1: Protein is the most important nutrient for athletes and helps to fuel performance

Fact: While protein does play a role in an athlete’s nutrition, it is, in fact, not the main nutrient that fuels performance. Protein’s role in the body is muscle repair and muscle growth. Carbohydrates are the body’s main source of energy, and the easiest source of energy for your body to use. Not getting enough carbohydrates is actually linked with decreased performance outcomes. Without enough carbohydrates to use for energy, your body will not be able to build muscle efficiently. Building muscle might be your primary goal, but your body’s primary goal is survival. Your body is going to prioritize fueling itself for day to day functioning and to get you through that next practice or game before it is going to focus on building muscle. Your body will also not hesitate to break down your muscles in the absence of carbohydrates as a means to make sure it has enough energy to function. Protein is not to be ignored completely. But increasing protein on its own is not going to lead to increases in performance or energy.

Myth #2: The lower my weight is, the faster I will be

Fact: If you are a runner, you’ve probably heard some tell you that being lighter will make you faster. And that might be your experience initially. But this improvement in performance is often short lived. Things will be okay until they aren’t. And we don’t know when things will stop being okay. Weight loss is a result of underfueling. And underfueling, paired with an intense exercise regimen can lead to lower bone density, hormone imbalances and increased fatigue. These factors increase your risk of developing a stress fracture. A stress fracture can put you out of training for up to 12 weeks. While you might notice an increase in performance in the short term, weight loss can lead to a decrease in performance in the long term. Weight loss also means muscle loss. Training is what impacts and improves your performance. And with weaker muscles, your training capacity will decrease. Eating enough is at the core of sustainable training. Proper fueling is how you can stay in your sport for the long haul.

Myth #3: Supplements are necessary for better performance

Fact: Supplements are meant to SUPPLEMENT an already adequate diet. Some supplements may provide small performance increases, but they are not magic. And most things you will get from a supplement can be gotten from foods. Not to mention that some supplements have more research to back them up than others. Supplements are also not regulated by the FDA the same way food products are. This means that we cannot fully trust what is on a supplement label; we cannot say for certain that the ingredients or amounts of ingredients are correct. Some supplement companies get their products 3rd party tested to assure that their ingredients list is accurate. If you are a NCAA athlete, this is even more important for you. Supplements that are not 3rd party tested may contain substances that are banned by the NCAA. These substances could result in a positive drug test, leading to the loss of a year of eligibility. It is important to note that just because a supplement is 3rd party tested, does not mean that it has scientific evidence to support its use. Before starting any supplement, it is best to run it by your sports dietitian first.

Myth #4: Dehydration is only a concern in hot weather

Fact: Dehydration is a concern in ALL weather. Hot. Cold. Rain. Snow. All of it. In fact, the myth that dehydration is only a concern in the warmer months is how athletes end up being dehydrated more often. While they might not feel overheated, even in colder weather, athletes are still sweating. Athletes often might not feel as thirsty in the colder months which can also lead to higher rates of dehydration. In order to stay hydrated, no matter what the weather is, focus on consuming fluids regularly, not just when you’re thirsty. When you’re feeling thirsty, chances are, you are already on your way to being dehydrated. Carrying a water bottle with you throughout the day can make drinking enough water a lot easier. While water is the “best” hydrator, other liquids such as juice, milk, tea, sports drinks, etc will also contribute to hydration status. Foods can also help with hydration status. Fruits and veggies with a higher water content, such as watermelon, cucumbers, lettuce, or tomatoes, can help you stay hydrated. Carbohydrates play a role in hydration by helping to retain and absorb fluids and electrolytes to keep up hydration status.

Myth #5: Sugar free Gatorade is better for athletes to consume than regular Gatorade.

Fact: Sugar free Gatorade also means carb-free Gatorade. Everyone talks about electrolytes being the purpose of Gatorade. And while they are a benefit, another benefit of Gatorade is the carbohydrate content. Carbohydrates help to absorb the electrolytes. And help the body retain water to contribute to hydration status. In sugar free Gatorade, the carbs are missing. Because there are no carbs, there is decreased electrolyte absorption which can have a negative impact on hydration status. Not to mention the carbohydrates also provide energy that athletes can use before, during and after training. This can be particularly helpful for athletes who struggle to eat solid foods around training and find it easier to drink something.

Final Thoughts on Finding the Right Nutrition for Athletes

Thank you for reading this blog about nutrition myths and athletes. Busting these common misconceptions highlights one key truth: performance starts with proper fueling. Carbs, hydration, and overall energy intake matter more than trendy shortcuts like cutting sugar or overloading on protein. When athletes focus on balanced, evidence-based nutrition, they set themselves up for long-term success and health.

Contact Us

Courage to Nourish is a group of eating disorder specialized dietitians. We have in person locations in Alexandria, Virginia, Columbia, Maryland and College Park, Maryland. We offer virtual services across the state of Virginia, Washington DC, Pennsylvania, and Colorado. We offer individual nutrition therapy. As well as support groups. We would love to guide you in building a better relationship with food.

Contact us for more information. And to schedule a discovery call. Also, sign up for our client or clinician newsletter!

Take one of our eating disorder quizzes:

Kathryn Karukas

Kathyrn Karukas, MS, RD, LD

Kathryn is a weight-inclusive, anti-diet eating disorder dietitian at Courage to Nourish. She specializes in working with adolescents and families, athletes, and individuals recovering from ARFID. Kathryn sees clients in person at the Columbia, Maryland office and virtually throughout Virginia, Pennsylvania, DC, and Maryland. To schedule a discovery call with Kathryn, click here.